Sauce recipe· 7 ingredientsno ratings yet

Chicago Deep Dish Chunky Sauce

Barely cooked, deliberately chunky. Hand-crushed whole tomatoes; the long bake does the cooking.

⏱ Total
10 min
✋ Active
10 min
◆ Difficulty
Easy
Chicago Deep Dish Chunky Sauce

Intro

Barely cooked, deliberately chunky. Hand-crushed whole tomatoes, garlic, oregano, salt. Goes on top of the cheese, inside the pan, and bakes for 25+ minutes — so it doesn't need pre-cooking. The chunkiness is the point. Resist the urge to blend.

◆ How many g (~2.5 pies)?
g (~2.5 pies)
◆ What tools do you have?
0.1g precision

Ingredients

For 900 G (~2.5 PIES)
Whole peeled San Marzano tomatoes
800 g28.2 oz

note · Hand-crushed. The chunkiness is the point.

Reserved tomato juice (add back)
100 ml1/2 cup · 3.4 fl oz

note · Save the rest for pasta water.

Extra virgin olive oil
15 g1 Tbsp
Garlic, finely minced
15 g0.5 oz

note · ~4 cloves.

Dried oregano
3 g0.1 oz

note · ~1½ tsp.

Fine sea salt
7 g1 1/4 tsp
Sugar
3 g0.1 oz

The process

  1. 1

    Drain & reserve

    Drain the tomatoes 800 g briefly, reserving 100 ml of the juice. Discard or save the rest for pasta water.

  2. 2

    Hand-crush

    Crush the tomatoes by hand into rough chunks in a bowl. You want pieces, not a purée.

  3. 3

    Combine

    Add the 100 ml reserved juice back. Stir in the olive oil 15 g, garlic 15 g, oregano 3 g, salt 7 g, sugar 3 g.

  4. 4

    Rest

    Let sit 10 minutes for the garlic to mellow into the sauce before topping the pizza.

    ✶ Pizzaiolo tip
    If you want the Lou Malnati's version, add 1 tsp of dried Italian herb blend.
    Rest10:00

Notes from the kitchen

Sign in to leave a note.

No notes yet. Be the first.

From the pizzaioli

No pies yet. Be the first.

+ Add your pie

The goods