Sicilian & Grandma
Same dough, same pan, two finishes. Grandma is thinner; Sicilian is thicker with a longer second rise.

Intro
Grandma: thinner, crispier bottom, no extended second proof, cheese before sauce. Sicilian: thicker, focaccia-like, 1β2 hour second proof in the oiled pan, sauce before cheese. Cheese-then-sauce (Grandma) creates the iconic mottled red-and-white look and protects the crust.
Ingredients
Sized for 1 Γ half-sheet pan (13Γ18) (1 pan of 1 pan/batch Β· 1Γ batch)
note Β· Bread flour, not 00 β you need the protein for the high hydration and pan press.
note Β· 70% hydration.
Sized for 1 Γ half-sheet pan (13Γ18) (250 g of 500 g/batch Β· 0.5Γ batch)
note Β· ~4 cloves. Microplaned dissolves into the sauce; minced gives little bursts of flavor.
note Β· ~1 tsp.
note Β· ~Β½ tsp.
note Β· Off heat β heat destroys the perfume.
Sized for 1 Γ half-sheet pan (13Γ18) (300 g of 350 g/batch Β· 0.86Γ batch)
note Β· Galbani, Polly-O, Boar's Head, or your local deli's house block. Whole milk β not part-skim.
The process
- β DOUGH
Sicilian / Grandma Dough
β - 1
Mix & knead
Mix the flour 500 g, salt 10 g, yeast 2 g in the bowl. Add the water 350 ml and the 15 g of in-dough oil. Knead on low for 5 minutes until cohesive.
β± Knead05:00 - 2
Bulk ferment
Bulk ferment 1 hour at room temp.
β± Bulk60:00 - 3
Cold ferment
Refrigerate 12β48 hours.
β± Cold ferment720:00 - 4
Press into pan
Pour 30 g olive oil into a half-sheet. Tip the dough in, turn to coat, then press to the corners with oiled fingers. Rest 15 minutes between attempts if it resists.
β± Press rests15:00 - β
Choose your finish
- 5
Grandma β top & bake now
Once the dough reaches the corners, top immediately and bake. Cheese first, then sauce dolloped over.
- 6
Sicilian β second proof
Cover the pan with plastic, proof 1β2 hours until visibly puffed and bubbly. Then top sauce-first, cheese over.
βΆ Pizzaiolo tipIf after 2 hours the dough is dense and tight, give it another 30 minutes.β± Second proof90:00 - β SAUCE
Classic Cooked Pizza Sauce
β - 7
Warm the oil
Warm the olive oil 12.5 g in a saucepan over medium-low heat.
- 8
Bloom the garlic
Add the garlic 7.5 g. Cook 30β60 seconds, stirring, until fragrant but not browned.
βΆ Pizzaiolo tipBurnt garlic is bitter β do not let it color.β± Bloom01:00 - 9
Add tomatoes & seasonings
Add the crushed tomatoes 400 g, oregano 1 g, salt 3 g, sugar 2 g, and red pepper 0.5 g if using. Stir.
- 10
Simmer
Simmer uncovered 15β20 minutes, stirring occasionally, until thickened to a spreadable consistency that mounds on a spoon.
βΆ Pizzaiolo tipIf it's still watery after 20 minutes, simmer another 5β10.β± Simmer18:00 - 11
Finish with basil
Off heat, stir in the torn basil 3.5 leaves. Cool. Taste and adjust salt.
- β CHEESE
Block Mozzarella Prep
β - 12
Buy block, not bag
Buy whole-milk low-moisture mozzarella in a block. Pre-shredded cheese is coated with cellulose and won't melt the same way.
- 13
Chill before grating
Chill the cheese 30 minutes in the freezer. Cold cheese grates cleanly without smearing.
β± Chill30:00 - 14
Grate
Grate on the large holes of a box grater, or the grating disc on a food processor for larger amounts.
- 15
Surface-dry 15 min
Spread on a tray and let sit at room temperature 15 minutes. This dries the surface slightly and improves melt.
βΆ Pizzaiolo tipFor grandma-style, mix in 50g of grated low-moisture mozzarella + 30g grated Parmesan for the iconic salty-nutty top.β± Surface-dry15:00 - 16
Use or freeze
Use within 24 hours of grating, or freeze for up to a month.
- 17
Preheat
Preheat oven to 500Β°F on the lower rack.
β± Preheat60:00 - β
Grandma (cheese-first)
- 18
Grandma top
Once dough reaches the corners, top immediately β mozzarella 300 g first, sauce 250 g dolloped over, Parmesan 15 g, herbs.
- 19
Grandma bake
Bake 18β22 minutes until the bottom is deeply browned and the cheese is bubbling and spotted.
β± Bake (Grandma)20:00 - β
Sicilian (sauce-first, second proof)
- 20
Sicilian top
After the 1β2 hour second proof, top sauce-first then cheese.
- 21
Sicilian bake
Bake 22β28 minutes until the bottom is deeply browned.
β± Bake (Sicilian)25:00 - 22
Cool on a rack
Slide out onto a wire rack immediately to keep the bottom crisp. Cut into squares.
βΆ Pizzaiolo tipUse a dark pan if you can. Light aluminum pans give pale, soft bottoms.
Notes from the kitchen
No notes yet. Be the first.
From the pizzaioli
No pies yet. Be the first.
More like this
The goods










